Baron 1, Lorelei 0
Two seasons I have followed pretty closely this autumn: Season Seven of The Gilmore Girls and the 2006 part of the '06-'07 NBA campaign of the Golden State Warriors. The Warriors have gone twelve (or is it thirteen?) seasons out of the playoffs and The Gilmore Girls is in its third season out of my heart--and yet I follow both entities.
The Warriors have always been my local team and I've rooted for them since I was a kid. That's a lotta heartbreak and boredom, people. But I love pro basketball, and that's what I've had to work with. Up until last season I lived without cable so it was difficult to follow the rest of the league except for when they were killing the W's or until the playoffs began. Nowadays thanks to cable (thanks, Psychedelic Eskimo!) I can partially watch the W's do battle and also impartially watch other teams play. I almost enjoy the impartial watching the most because I can appreciate a Gilbert Arenas vs. Steve Nash matchup without getting personally involved (still, I rooted for the Arenas and the Wizards).
Anyway, I'm enjoying the Warriors this season, even some of the losses, because of the play of Baron Davis. Sure, he sometimes takes three pointers when he shouldn't, or tries to drive the lane against five defenders, but mostly he's been a true warrior, taking over games, playing with that self-possessed but unconscious flow that maybe I've experienced a couple of times in my basketball playing life. It's like sex, zen, jazz, dessert...
My main point here is that good things have happened for the Warriors this season when the ball is in Baron's hands, and the same could be said for the Gilmore Girls when the dialogue is coming out of Lauren Graham/Lorelei Gilmore's mouth. Say what? Just stay with me here...For devoted Gilmore watchers, it was always about the dialogue, especially the snappy, self-conscious, self-doubting, self-absorbed, dialogue of Lorelei Gilmore. Few things on TV have been more entertaining for me over the years than watching Lorelei try to talk her way out of a discovered lie or a bad personal decision. What makes these scenes interesting isn't that Lorelei is trying to get one over on people it's that she's wrestling with her moral conscience (in that sense, she's a lot like Tony Soprano). We know Lorelei wants to do the right thing, but she's flawed, just like the rest of us. But considerably wittier.
What sort of dialogue has been written for Lorelei Gilmore this season? Angry, self-deluded, mushy, confused, humorless. And why is this? Because the Sherman-Palladinos, the creators of the show, left her character (and the show) in a cul-de-sac at the end of last season? David Rosenthal, the new head writer, has had a hell of a time working out of this mess, and I don't think he's succeeded. The Luke-Christopher silent fight, as I've written before, is the perfect metaphor for this season. In some ways, the current season of the Gilmores is a lot like last year's Warriors--Baron Davis, frustrated with his coach and his cloddish teammates (not counting JRich) chucking up desperation threes with plenty of time left on the 24 second clock.
Well, this season the W's new coach, Don Nelson, is having a better season than the Gilmores' new coach. Like the W's, the Gilmores are having a .500ish season (creativity wise), maybe their Nielsen ratings are higher than that? Okay, the shaky analogy is breaking down. I guess my ultimate point is that it's a lot more of a pleasure watching Baron do his thing this season than it is to watch Lorelei G/Lauren G. Ultimately, Baron is getting the chance to write a better script. A pity.
The Warriors have always been my local team and I've rooted for them since I was a kid. That's a lotta heartbreak and boredom, people. But I love pro basketball, and that's what I've had to work with. Up until last season I lived without cable so it was difficult to follow the rest of the league except for when they were killing the W's or until the playoffs began. Nowadays thanks to cable (thanks, Psychedelic Eskimo!) I can partially watch the W's do battle and also impartially watch other teams play. I almost enjoy the impartial watching the most because I can appreciate a Gilbert Arenas vs. Steve Nash matchup without getting personally involved (still, I rooted for the Arenas and the Wizards).
Anyway, I'm enjoying the Warriors this season, even some of the losses, because of the play of Baron Davis. Sure, he sometimes takes three pointers when he shouldn't, or tries to drive the lane against five defenders, but mostly he's been a true warrior, taking over games, playing with that self-possessed but unconscious flow that maybe I've experienced a couple of times in my basketball playing life. It's like sex, zen, jazz, dessert...
My main point here is that good things have happened for the Warriors this season when the ball is in Baron's hands, and the same could be said for the Gilmore Girls when the dialogue is coming out of Lauren Graham/Lorelei Gilmore's mouth. Say what? Just stay with me here...For devoted Gilmore watchers, it was always about the dialogue, especially the snappy, self-conscious, self-doubting, self-absorbed, dialogue of Lorelei Gilmore. Few things on TV have been more entertaining for me over the years than watching Lorelei try to talk her way out of a discovered lie or a bad personal decision. What makes these scenes interesting isn't that Lorelei is trying to get one over on people it's that she's wrestling with her moral conscience (in that sense, she's a lot like Tony Soprano). We know Lorelei wants to do the right thing, but she's flawed, just like the rest of us. But considerably wittier.
What sort of dialogue has been written for Lorelei Gilmore this season? Angry, self-deluded, mushy, confused, humorless. And why is this? Because the Sherman-Palladinos, the creators of the show, left her character (and the show) in a cul-de-sac at the end of last season? David Rosenthal, the new head writer, has had a hell of a time working out of this mess, and I don't think he's succeeded. The Luke-Christopher silent fight, as I've written before, is the perfect metaphor for this season. In some ways, the current season of the Gilmores is a lot like last year's Warriors--Baron Davis, frustrated with his coach and his cloddish teammates (not counting JRich) chucking up desperation threes with plenty of time left on the 24 second clock.
Well, this season the W's new coach, Don Nelson, is having a better season than the Gilmores' new coach. Like the W's, the Gilmores are having a .500ish season (creativity wise), maybe their Nielsen ratings are higher than that? Okay, the shaky analogy is breaking down. I guess my ultimate point is that it's a lot more of a pleasure watching Baron do his thing this season than it is to watch Lorelei G/Lauren G. Ultimately, Baron is getting the chance to write a better script. A pity.
